Pantagraph.com Weather forecast, local radar and more
NewsMonday, October 23, 2006 12:52 AM CDT
Fast-growing Indian community more visible
Advertisement

EDISON, N.J. -- The train station billboards tell it all. Local travel agents promise the best airfares from New York to Mumbai. Shagun Fashions is selling dazzling Indian saris. And DirecTV offers "the six top Indian channels direct to you."

Roughly every third person who lives Edison, a New York suburb, is of Asian Indian ancestry. Many are new immigrants who have come to work as physicians, engineers and high-tech experts and are drawn to "Little India" by convenience - it's near the commuter train - and familiarity.

Here they can "get their groceries and goods from home," says Aruna Rao, a mental health counselor who lives in town.

Although a steady stream of Indians have settled in the U.S. since the 1960s, immigrants positively poured into the country between 2000 and 2005 — arriving at a higher rate than any other group.

Not only is the Indian community burgeoning, it's maturing. Increasingly, after decades of quietly establishing themselves, Indians are becoming more vocal in the American conversation — about politics, ethnicity and many other topics.

"I've been studying the community for 20 years and in the last four or five years something different has been happening," said Madhulika Khandelwal, president of the Asian American Center at Queens College in New York. "Indian-Americans are finally out there speaking for themselves."

Roughly 2.3 million people of Indian ancestry, including immigrants and the American-born, now call the U.S. home, according to 2005 Census data. That's up from 1.7 million in 2000.

They have big communities in New Jersey, New York, California and Texas, and their average yearly household income is more than $60,000 — 35 percent higher than the nation overall. Indian Americans, along with Indian expatriates worldwide, sent about $23 billion back to India in 2005, World Bank data show.

And so when Virginia Sen. George Allen was caught on video in August calling an Indian American man "macaca" — a type of monkey and an offensive term — the community quickly responded.

Within days after the reports emerged, Sanjay Puri, founder of the U.S. Indian Political Action Committee, and other Indian leaders in the Washington, D.C., area requested and got a lengthy meeting with Allen, Puri said. The senator publicly apologized.

If this had happened 10 years ago?

"It would have been a lot harder," Puri said. "But this is a prosperous and fast-growing community. People are beginning to understand that we are contributing politically, so that made a big difference."

Many Indian immigrants arrived in the U.S. focused almost entirely on individual success — getting a top-notch job, making good money and pushing their children to do the same.

But things are changing. After the Sept. 11 attacks, many Indian Sikhs, who wear turbans as part of their faith, were mistaken for Muslims — and terrorists. Hundreds were harassed or worse: In Mesa, Ariz., a Sikh gas station owner was shot and killed on Sept. 15, 2001, by a man who told police "all Arabs had to be shot."

Few knew their rights because few had been engaged politically, said Amardeep Singh, executive director of The Sikh Coalition in New York.

"We were caught with our pants down," he said. "Sept. 11 created a confrontation. We realized we now need to actively involve ourselves in the policy-making process. Otherwise policies will be made that exclude us."

The group now has two bills pending in the New York city council — one would allow city employees to wear turbans and the other would make city officials craft plans to prevent hate crimes if another terrorist attack happened. The community recently saw three Sikhs elected to low-level offices around the city. "It's a good first step," Singh said.

The push extends beyond Sikhs, Puri said.

"The question that every Indian-American is asking lately: Is the American dream — making a lot of money and having fancy cars — enough?" he said. "Giving back and being active is also happening."

In New Jersey, Ready to Run, a Rutgers University-based project that helps women seek public office, will next year for the first time court Asian women, said Reema Desai, an immigration lawyer who is helping organize the outreach.

Indians also are working outside politics to influence broader society. They are overrepresented among college professors, engineers and technology workers. Between 10 percent and 12 percent of all medical school students are Indians, according to the American Association of Physicians of Indian Origin, the biggest physicians' group in the nation after the American Medical Association.

Half of all motel rooms in the nation are owned by Indians, according to the Asian American Hotel Owners Association.

In New York City, Basement Banghra, a popular Indian music event that blends hip-hop rhythms with Indian melodies, attracts hundreds of partygoers to Sounds of Brazil nightclub each month. It will mark its 10th anniversary next year.

There are novelists, including Pulitzer Prize winner Jhumpa Lahiri of Brooklyn; filmmakers like Mira Nair, whose "The Namesake," based on Lahiri's novel and distributed by Fox Searchlight Pictures, is due in theaters next spring; and prime-time television stars such as Parminder Nagra on "E.R." and Naveen Andrews on "Lost."

"Many of these things are converging around the same time, so it all adds up," Khandelwal said. "It seems like every other day there's a big book or movie or high-profile accomplishment."

Increasingly, American-born Indians — who call themselves Desis — have the confidence to make their voices heard. "There is a clear rise of this generation," she said.

With rapid growth, the community is becoming more complex.

Layered atop the dizzying diversity of India itself — there are dozens of languages, and distinct regional differences in culture, politics and cuisine — are growing class differences among Indian-Americans.

About one-tenth live in poverty, and as many as 400,000 are undocumented, said Deepa Iyer, executive director of South Asian American Leaders of Tomorrow in Takoma Park, Md.

"This is a community of contrasts," Iyer said. "We hear so much about this highly educated and affluent group, but we also have segments that are not fluent in English and are battling immigration problems and hate crimes."

Such topics are often discussed in New Jersey, home to 170,000 Asian Indians as of Census 2000. Many have fresh memories of gangs of anti-Indian white youth in the late 1980s in Jersey City — then the nexus of the state's Indian community — who called themselves Dotbusters, referring to the decorative bindi some Hindi women wear between their eyebrows. In 1987, a finance manager was beaten to death with a baseball bat while his attackers shouted "Hindu! Hindu!"

Such crimes have diminished, but they never disappeared, said Singh of The Sikh Coalition. Last year, he said, two Sikh youth suffered violent harassment in New Jersey public schools.

In Edison in recent years, there's been low-grade tension between Indians and police, residents said, and it erupted during this year's July 4 celebrations. Police were called to a heavily Indian apartment complex to disperse a crowd of nearly 800, and one Indian man said he was beaten by police, said Jerry Barca, spokesman for Edison's mayor.

When the community held a protest the next month, the man was arrested on the spot for being an illegal immigrant. He remains in federal custody.

"There's definitely tension and suspicion," said Rao, who has lived in Edison for seven years and said the problems have left some Indians disillusioned. "People feel like, 'What am I doing in this country?' A lot of it is, 'I told you so. We'll never be accepted or assimilated.'" She added that there are no Indians on Edison's school board or city council.

City officials called on state mediators to help build bridges in the community, and the advisory body includes two Indian-Americans, Barca said. "It's going to take time, but it's good because now people in Edison are talking - as opposed to `you live over there and we live over here,'" he said.

Desai, the immigration lawyer, has lived in New Jersey since she was 3, and said she sees many signs of positive change compared to a generation ago.

"We've made an impact in all sorts of things, and now you even have people knowing about our holidays and our culture," she said. "Things are different now. We're more visible."

Take a look
Amardeep Singh, executive director of The Sikh Coalition, and Mehtab Kaur, left, the organization's civil rights advocate, work at its headquarters in New York, Tuesday Oct. 10, 2006. Singh referred to a resolution by the U.S. Senate supporting the organization's aims, displayed as a large wall poster, right, opposing bigotry and violence against Sihk Americans, written in both English and Punjabi languages. (AP Photo/Bebeto Matthews)
A woman wearing a sari, traditional Indian clothing, stands in front of clothing store displaying more modern Indian outfits Saturday, Oct. 14, 2006 in Iselin, N.J. Many Asian Indians live in the area. (AP Photo/Mel Evans)
Aruna Rao, near left, shops at the Indian supermarket Apna Bazar Cash & Carry on Saturday, Oct. 14, 2006 in Edison, N.J. In Edison, roughly one-third of the population, like Rao, is of Asian Indian ancestry. (AP Photo/Mel Evans)
Video
Most commented stories
Browse online archives
Recent issues:
Reader comments on this story - 27 total

Note: All views and opinions expressed in reader comments are solely those of the individual submitting the comment, and not those of the Pantagraph or its staff.

JimmyTheBuddha wrote on Oct 26, 2006 9:18 AM:

" Did I stutter? "

To Jimmy the Buddah wrote on Oct 25, 2006 6:09 PM:

" I work in a high-tech environment and the last Indian gentleman I worked with put in 13 hour days, did excellent work, and didn't complain about a thing. "

JimmyTheBuddha wrote on Oct 25, 2006 8:51 AM:

" Fine. Don't apologize. Stick to your guns (metaphorical guns, I hope). But we should take down the "Racism: Not in Our Town" signs based on this message board alone. We wouldn't want to be accused of false advertising. All's fair in capitalism, baby. I work in a high-tech environment and the last Indian gentleman I worked with put in 13 hour days, did excellent work, and didn't complain about a thing. When you compare that to the attitude of the Americans around me... I'm sorry, "I just don't get it", but I was born and raised in America and most of the time I don't respect our culture. Maybe there's something to learn from a new challenge. Maybe it's time we stepped up our game instead of throwing impotent "slurpee" remarks at our new neighbors. "

i just don't get (again) wrote on Oct 24, 2006 7:49 AM:

" to: you obviously don't get it: i didn't say anything about muslim or hinduism. all i know is the people that were responsible for 9/11 looked like the man in the picture with a turbin on his head. all of these people love our freedoms but look at americans with discuss. i'm not saying if you love this country you must adopt our culture, but you have to respect it. To: for i just don't get it: i don't know what religion you are talking about but, their religion is base on a Jihad- a war between muslims and christians. today's society is based on assumptions. the only people i see blowing stuff up is people with dark skin, wearing turbins, and smelling bad. I WILL NOT APOLOGIZE! "

I would like to see wrote on Oct 24, 2006 6:09 AM:

" An Indian family travel on veterans in authentic clothing, atop an Indian elephant. "

good ol days wrote on Oct 24, 2006 5:46 AM:

" seems to me not so long ago India was among the poorest of countys . around a billion people with much poverty and hunger . a cow could walk down the street worshipped while ten familys starved . It seems i recall our parents working hard in industry and factorys and trades and buisness of all kinds thus helping other countrys and offering them the opportunity through grants and scholarships to be able study and be taught at our universitys . I "have" noticed that some of them seem to be the most patient and polite people i've ever met . "

TO: Born in the USA wrote on Oct 23, 2006 8:16 PM:

" Are you afraid of a little competition? It's called capitalism. If one store has a better price, don't you go there instead? And yeah, my job is one of the types being outsourced, but I try to be a good employee, make myself valuable to the company, and that's all I can do. I certainly don't hold it against any of the people from India. They're just taking the best job they can get and making a better life for their families just like everybody else. I'd do the same thing if I were in their shoes. "

Indian Friend wrote on Oct 23, 2006 7:37 PM:

" Where the world is becoming a global village, quality will make it mark everywhere. Everyone knows if you want to get things done give it to Indians to do. You should thank to India to loan such talent to america and contribute in the success of american companies. Its better than American multinationals dumping their waste in India in the name of food drinks and fastfood chains... Its all gain for America, why people still cry foul ? "

To Bloomington Driver: wrote on Oct 23, 2006 5:19 PM:

" Bad Indian drivers???? Are you blind? I can't believe that something isn't being done about speeding and tailing. Nothing is being done, it keeps going on and more and more are doing it. And you say Indians are bad drivers? I've noticed they drive the speed limit...is there something wrong with that? The other day I saw an American lady driving down Hershey, in the dark, with an interior light on, reading a book! "

"How do this country don't need wrote on Oct 23, 2006 5:03 PM:

" immigrants anymore?" Why government think tanks in Washington have positive attitude towards this community? If they are not allowed here they will go elsewhere in some other country e.g. China. This will help China become super power sooner than it is expected to. Who will loose????? "

well wisher wrote on Oct 23, 2006 5:00 PM:

" The people of Indian origin are very highly educated, work hard and work well and also do very well in giving back to the community. Our country needs more and more of such good quality immigrants. They have made our country strong with excellent infrastructure. We need to encourage more and more such immigrants from India. In fact, we should petition our government to increase the visa numbers to allow more and more such hard working and highly educated Indian immigrants into the country. "

Born in the USA wrote on Oct 23, 2006 4:20 PM:

" How can anyone be "for" all of this. They are taking over too may jobs. Those who are making the positive comments evidently don't work, don't have to work, and have spouses that make so much money they don't have to worry. Or maybe your spouse is the CEO of the company where they are hiring indians because they work cheaper and it puts the same amount of money, including bonuses in the CEO's pocket. You should all be ashamed of yourselves. But then how do I know it isn't the Indian community making these positive comments? I don't have a thing against them if they stay where they were born. We needed immigrants at one time to build our country, but we don't need them anymore! "

To Bloomington Driver wrote on Oct 23, 2006 3:48 PM:

" If there are some bad Indian drivers, I have trouble picking them out every other bad driver in this area. I often wonder if people around here found their license in a Cracker Jack box. "

If we won't wrote on Oct 23, 2006 2:17 PM:

" capitalize on this opportunity to go to Mexico they will one day. How about New Mexico becoming new India in our neighborhood?? We need to keep the best brains in the world (Indians) at home and keep our doors open for them to make our companies more competitive in the world. "

A Local from Bloomington, IL wrote on Oct 23, 2006 1:41 PM:

" "Just to share with all of you, Indian Community from Bloomiongton, IL has donated a Truck load of Food Items to the Local Charities like Home Sweet Home, Clare House, Safe Arbor on the Day of their Festival called Diwali on 21st Oct. 2006 I think that has made a great difference.. We nned to appreciat the Great contribution given by Inidan Community." "

Nitin S wrote on Oct 23, 2006 1:21 PM:

" Its good to see Media giving attention to Indian community. "

Livingston county Reader wrote on Oct 23, 2006 1:14 PM:

" Lets send them to Mexico? Why not? If they are so great they can turn that country around in no time at all. I am told Mexico is about empty anyway..plenty of room. "

TooMany wrote on Oct 23, 2006 12:39 PM:

" There are too many of them (indians) here. Taking the good paying jobs away from Americans. Where I work (in a high tech field), american workers are being replaced by indian workers. Because, they can get indian workers for about 1/4 the price of an american worker. "

these guys are amazing wrote on Oct 23, 2006 11:50 AM:

" I tried to learn more and they have significant contribution to our Country's growth. Visit following URL link to know more about them. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_American Anybody herd of "zippies", there are 500 millions of them under the age of 25 present in the India, waiting to change the world in coming decades. "

Bloomington Driver wrote on Oct 23, 2006 10:24 AM:

" They are OK but someone needs to teach them how to drive! Bad!! "

To: For "I Just Dont Get" wrote on Oct 23, 2006 10:22 AM:

" Along with the praises go the bad things also..The have an organized crime problem that makes our Mafia look like beginners. While you were 'singing' I thought you could sing it all. "

To: i just don't get... wrote on Oct 23, 2006 9:36 AM:

" Yeah, you don't get it. I hope you're just trolling for a response and not serious. I don't believe there have been any Indians bombing us. Taking the good white collar jobs, yes, but bombing us, no. "

do... wrote on Oct 23, 2006 9:36 AM:

" we get a slurpee with that? "

for "i just don't get" wrote on Oct 23, 2006 9:21 AM:

" Go to the following recent NY Times and BusinessWeek articles about Indians and their culture and learn more about how these people can make this world a better place to live. The religion they follow is the most tolerent and peace loving, dude. Learn better about them and then you will never comment about them. http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/us/AP-Indian-America.html?pagewanted=1&_r=2 http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/06_44/b4007091.htm?chan=top+news_top+news+index_businessweek+exclusives "

You obviously don't get it wrote on Oct 23, 2006 9:18 AM:

" You need a geography lesson. There are some Muslim people in India (just like the US), but the majority are Hindus, and the man pictured in the article is a Sikh, also not a Muslim. They had nothing to do with 9/11 or any other terrorist attacks. Your comment is at best ignorant and at worst racist. "

i just don't get... wrote on Oct 23, 2006 8:59 AM:

" why we let SO many in after we were bombed by them! "

We have our own wrote on Oct 23, 2006 8:09 AM:

" "Little India" growing, and I love it. I hope to see our Indian population become more visible and vocal in the community. "

Add your own comments

Please read the rules before posting comments.

You must be logged in to leave comments.
If you don't have a member ID, please register.

*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
  Forgot Your Password?