Pantagraph.com Weather forecast, local radar and more
SportsFriday, August 24, 2007 11:49 PM CDT
Kindred: U of I makes right call in sitting Smith
Advertisement

Normally, second chances are given. This one must be earned. Applaud the University of Illinois for that. The powers that be in Champaign got it right in regard to embattled basketball player Jamar Smith.

The junior guard is not being handed his position. If he wants it back, he’ll have to work for it, wait for it. Trust and respect are earned over the long haul, and there will be no shortcuts for Smith.

His resolve will be tested every day for the next year, with a lot more eyes than Bruce Weber’s on him. Smith’s behavior will be subject to review in everything he does. If he truly has changed, and truly wants to be a productive citizen, student and player, he’ll have to prove it.

That is the only way this could work, really. Many believe Smith had his chance and blew it last February, when on a snowy night he drank himself into a stupor and wrecked his car into a tree, leaving his teammate and passenger, Brian Carlwell, with a severe concussion.

His blood-alcohol level at twice the legal limit, Smith left the scene and drove back to his apartment, further jeopardizing Carlwell’s health.

Ultimately, Smith pleaded guilty to aggravated driving under the influence of alcohol and served 15 days in jail. He also was placed on 24 months’ probation, given 100 hours of public service, fined $1,000 and sent to substance-abuse classes.

Weber suspended him for the final eight games of last season, and announced on Wednesday that Smith will be redshirted this year. If the sharpshooting guard from Peoria wants to play again in an Illini uniform, and he says he does, he’ll have to keep his nose clean and to the grindstone for another 12 months.

Reportedly, the decision to sit Smith came from above Weber. No matter, it was the right move. Smith says he has not taken a drink in six months, that he is a new person living a new life. The Illinois administration wants to be sure before allowing him to again represent the university.

That is not a lot to ask.

In fact, it is the responsibility of those in charge, from President B. Joseph White on down, to demand that Smith earn a second opportunity after squandering his first so badly, so publicly.

Illinois’ committee on student conduct ruled Smith should be allowed to remain in school, a first step in his road back. He began classes on Wednesday.

Course work aside, the real tests will come away from the classroom and the court, where Smith will be allowed to practice with the Illini.

He admitted during his legal troubles to drinking alcohol frequently in the year leading up to his accident. There will be temptation to fall back into that pattern when the games go on without him.

Frustration and free time can be a bad combination, and Smith will have both. How he handles that will determine whether or not he is worthy of a second chance.

Meanwhile, Smith will remain on scholarship. Perhaps he should have been made to earn that back as well. A full ride comes with expectations and responsibilities, and Smith failed to live up to either last year.

That said, this is ultimately about a young man turning his life around, and it is difficult to put a price on that. It is not about money as much as maturity, i.e. growing from one’s mistakes.

Smith wants us to believe he has grown up immensely, that he has learned to value sobriety and is committed to it. He wants us to believe he is ready to become a leader and role model on and off the court.

If he is, a year won’t change that.

If not, he’ll be out of chances … second or otherwise.

Randy Kindred is a Pantagraph columnist. To leave him a voice mail, call 820-3402. By e-mail: rkindred@pantagraph.com. The Randy Kindred Blog is at www.pantagraph.com/blogs

Get area high school sports scores and statistics at Varsity Sports.

Video stories
Most commented stories
Community calendar
Browse online archives
Recent issues:
Scores, stats, standings & more
Get the latest in all your favorite sports
MLB: Main | Scoreboard NFL: Main | Scoreboard NBA: Main | Scoreboard
NHL: Main | Scoreboard NCAA FB: Main | Scoreboard NCAA BK: Main | Scoreboard
Golf: Main | Leaderboard Auto Racing: Main | Results Tennis: Main | Scoreboard
High School: Varsity Sports Main | BHS | NCHS | NCWHS | CCHS | U High | More schools...
Area College: ISU MBK (MVC Scoreboard) | ISU WBK (MVC) | ISU FB (Gateway)
Area College: Illinois MBK (Big Ten Scoreboard) | Illinois WBK (Big Ten) | Illinois FB (Big Ten)
More: Extreme | PrairieThunder | MLS | NCAA WBK | WNBA | Arena FB | CFL | NFL Draft | NBA Draft
Reader comments on this story - 9 total

Note: All views and opinions expressed in reader comments are solely those of the individual submitting the comment, and not those of the Pantagraph or its staff.

bgdaddy wrote on Aug 24, 2007 6:54 PM:

" No one should be tried twice the law had already punished this young man and he also had to sit out very crucial games last year. no one should be punished by the law and then by there employer or school. "

He left wrote on Aug 24, 2007 5:45 PM:

" a kid for dead! He should be thrown out of the university, no second chance. Give the scholarship to someone who has respect for the university and deserves it. This kid doesn't. "

AP wrote on Aug 24, 2007 5:27 PM:

" Did Smith lose his license in with the rest of the consequences? "

I agree wrote on Aug 24, 2007 3:00 PM:

" Weber is promoting bad behavior -- but if you can shoot the rock baby -- it don't matter. "

bgdaddy wrote on Aug 24, 2007 2:03 PM:

" the right call for who? someone that doesnt care about the kids are the school . "

Candy Man wrote on Aug 24, 2007 1:00 PM:

" Weber is "redshirting" him this season. Did he also give him a lollipop and a pat on the head? "

I agree with wrote on Aug 24, 2007 12:42 PM:

" Weber no guts. No reason this kid should still be playing basketball, at least not at the U of I. "

Weber no guts wrote on Aug 24, 2007 11:06 AM:

" The kid should have lost his scholarship. Red shirting kid who will take 5 years to complete his degree is no punishment. Weber has not taught this kid any discipline, but is only promoting more bad behavoir in the future. I think Mcbride and others prove my point. "

Truman the Tiger wrote on Aug 24, 2007 9:28 AM:

" All good points. I especially agree that he should be made to earn the scholarship back by working in another capacity at the university given that he won't be earning it on the court. "

Add your own comments

Please read the rules before posting comments.

You must be logged in to leave comments.
If you don't have a member ID, please register.

*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
  Forgot Your Password?