Pantagraph.com Weather forecast, local radar and more
NewsThursday, October 18, 2007 1:23 PM CDT
Frustrated senior takes a whack at cable company
Advertisement

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Sometimes truly American virtues arise in outlaws who — by dint of heroic but questionable endeavors — display the mettle of the national character.

For instance: The Dillinger Gang, robbing banks (and destroying mortgages) when banks were foreclosing on the poor. Stephanie St. Clair, matron of the numbers racket during the Harlem Renaissance, striking a (dubious) blow for both gender and racial equality. Junior Johnson bootlegging liquor during Prohibition (the benefits of which were self-evident).

Fear not, fellow Americans! In these dark days of war, pestilence and Paris Hilton, a new hero has arisen. She is none other than 75-year-old Mona “The Hammer” Shaw, who took the aforementioned implement to her local Com-cast office to settle a score, and boy, did she!

This was after the company had scheduled installation of its much ballyhooed “Triple Play” service, which com-bines phone, cable and Internet services, in Shaw’s brick home in suburban Bristow, Va. But Shaw said they failed to show up on the appointed day, Monday, Aug. 13. They came two days later but left with the job half done. On Friday morning, they cut off all service.

This was the company that has had consumer service problems serious enough to prompt the trade magazine Ad-vertising Age to editorialize that Comcast and other cable providers should spend less on advertising and more on customer service. And has spawned a blog called ComcastMustDie.com that’s filled with posts from angry customers.

So on that Friday, Mona Shaw and her husband, Don, went to the call center office in Manassas, Va., to complain.

Let’s pick it up, mid-action, according to Shaw:

Mona demands to speak to a manager. A customer service representative says someone will be right with them. Directs them to a bench, outside. (Remember, it’s mid-August.) Mona and Don sit.

Tick, tick, tick, goes the clock. Sit, sit, sit, go Mona and Don.

For. Two. Hours.

And then — this is the best part — the customer rep leans out the door and says the manager has left for the day. Thanks for coming!

Oh, the sputtering outrage!

The insulting idea that, as Shaw puts it, “they thought just because we’re old enough to get Social Security that we lack both brains AND backbone.”

So, after stewing over it all weekend, on the following Monday, she went downstairs, got Don’s claw hammer and said, “C’mon, honey, we’re going to Comcast.”

Did you try to stop her, Mr. Shaw?

“Oh no, no,” he says.

Hammer time: Shaw storms in the company’s office. BAM! She whacks the keyboard of the customer service rep. BAM! Down goes the monitor. BAM! She totals the telephone. People scatter, scream, cops show up and what does she do? POW! A parting shot to the phone!

“They cuffed me right then,” she says.

Her take on Comcast: “What a bunch of sub-moronic imbeciles.”

Being a responsible newspaper, we must note that this is a misdemeanor, a crime, a completely inappropriate way of handling a business dispute.

Noted.

Who among us has not longed for a hammer in this age of incompetent “customer service representatives,” of nim-rods reading from a script at some 800-number location, of crumbs-in-their-beards plumbing installation people who tell you they’ll grace you with their presence between 12 and 3, only never to show? And you’ll call and call and fi-nally some outsourced representative slings a dart at a calendar and tells you another guy will come back between 10 and 2 next Thursday? And when this guy comes, pants halfway down his behind, he’ll tell you he brought the wrong part?

And there is nothing, nothing you can do.

Until there! On the horizon! It’s Hammer Woman, avenger of oppressed cable subscribers everywhere! (Cue gallop-ing “Lone Ranger” theme.)

“I scared the tar out of some people, at least,” she says. “It had never occurred to me to take a hammer to a phone company before, but I was just so upset. ... After I hit the keyboard, I turned to this blonde who had been there the previous Friday, the one who told me to wait for the manager, and I said, ‘NOW do I have your attention?’ “

It wasn’t all fun.

“My blood pressure went up around my ears. I started hyperventilating. They had to call the rescue squad and put me on a litter.”

By the time it was over, she recalls, there were an ambulance, two police cruisers and a sergeant’s car in the park-ing lot. Shaw received a three-month suspended sentence for disorderly conduct, a $345 fine in restitution and a year-long restraining order barring her from the Comcast office.

“Truly a unique and inappropriate situation,” says Beth Bacha, a vice president for Comcast. She says company policy forbids disclosure of clients’ records, but did say their files note that the service record wasn’t exactly what Shaw has indicated. Besides, “nothing justifies this sort of dangerous behavior.”

Bacha noted that Comcast has more than 25 million customers, the overwhelming majority of which are very satis-fied with their service.

Manassas police spokesman Sgt. Tim Neumann says there have been other police calls to that Comcast office, but he doesn’t know what prompted them.

Bob Garfield, who runs ComcastMustDie.com, wrote last week he was happy the site had become an outlet for “so much deep-seated rage,” but hoped customers would “keep the hammer assaults down to a bare minimum.”

From what we can tell, Mona Shaw is not, actually, a raving lunatic armed with construction tools.

She is a nice lady who lives in a nice house. She and Don are both retired from the Air Force (she was a registered nurse). They have been married 45 years. She is secretary of the local AARP, secretary of a square-dancing club and takes in strays for the local animal shelter (they have seven dogs at the moment). She has a heart condition. She lifts weights at a local gym. The couple attend a Unitarian Universalist church.

Police gave her the hammer back, though she swears she’s content to ride off into the sunset of True Crime Stories in America, never again to go Com-smash-tic on her local cable provider.

She does, however, finally, have phone service.

On Verizon.

Video
Most commented stories
Browse online archives
Recent issues:
Reader comments on this story - 32 total

Note: All views and opinions expressed in reader comments are solely those of the individual submitting the comment, and not those of the Pantagraph or its staff.

the simple life wrote on Oct 27, 2007 8:30 AM:

" my home phone, cell phone, cable TV, and DSL provider are about 85 dollars a month all together. It works out fine, i have better things to do than watch television all day. And if I didn't have teenagers, i wouldn't have even all these things in my home. I don't think I'm better than anyone else, just more mature and sensible. "

Lousy service wrote on Oct 23, 2007 9:44 AM:

" Besides the bad service and customer abuse of these mega monstors, we pay for television and frequently are treated(?) to ads covering up to a third of the show we are trying to watch. Go get another hammer! "

Way to go Mona wrote on Oct 21, 2007 6:23 PM:

" Thank you, you are my hero. What is happening to our customer service? Why are all the big companies outsourcing to India? We can't understand them, they frustrate us, sometimes they even hang up in the middle of working out a problem and that is after we are on hold for EVER. Wake up BIG GUYS, WE ARE GETTING FED UP! ie Mona, my hero "

Kelley wrote on Oct 19, 2007 8:45 PM:

" Can we borrow this sweet ladt. Need someone with her expertise to work with our cable co. "

Ditch Mediacom wrote on Oct 19, 2007 4:08 PM:

" After mediacom screwed me out of last years Bears games, I switched to Directv. Installation was done very professionally, I have had no problems with it (unless it's raining horizontally, and then for a few minutes at most) and I pay a lot less because its bundled. The only downside is, now I can see all the Bears games, and they stink! "

Antenna wrote on Oct 19, 2007 1:34 PM:

" I can't get cable and satellite prices kept going up as well. I finally canceled it all and put up an antenna. I get free, HD programming with no customer service issues! I'm sure with the latest story about Comcast restricting bandwidth won't help their reputation any. I had no problem with the "Dish". "

They all suck... wrote on Oct 19, 2007 1:27 PM:

" We have Dish and it seems it is no better than cable some of the time. We used to live in Vermont, in the mountains, where there is cloud cover for (practically) 6 months out of the year. Had Dish there for over a year. It only went out once for about a minute. LOVED IT! Moved to Chicago and stuck with the Dish. Haven't even had it one year yet and it goes out ALL THE TIME and doesn't come on until the tech come out. And don't think the technicians are any better with Dish. They give you a 5 hour time period they will be there about a week after you make the complaint and if you aren't there, they charge you! Customer service is definitely a dying art... "

Jennifer Khoury wrote on Oct 19, 2007 12:55 PM:

" There have been many posts about the incident with Mona Shaw. We are sincerely sorry for the customer service issues that she experienced. Comcast has more than 225 million customer interactions a year and we are striving to deliver a positive experience to every customer, every time. However, it is also our responsibility as an employer to ensure the safety of our employees. Ms. Shaw's actions were certainly not appropriate under any circumstances and we hope that contributors to these online forums would discourage others from taking physical action against customer service employees. We'd like customers reading this post to know that we are undergoing a company-wide effort to improve customer service. More information about this effort and how to contact Comcast online can be found at www.comcast.com/customerservice. Jennifer Khoury, Comcast Corporation "

TO: WHY WHY WHY wrote on Oct 19, 2007 10:30 AM:

" DO NOT GO WITH SATELITTE SERVICE. I tell you this because I was a supervisor for their customer service deptartment (it doesn't matter which one they are both owned by the same company.) There were so many disputes and complaints that my team and I could have easily handled (within 5 minutes.) but because of corporate policy we would have to e-mail another department and they would take care of the issue within 6 mos. meanwhile the customers credit was being ruined as they were sent to collections for thousands of dollars they didn't owe and were still expected to wait 6 mos to get this corrected when we could have done it with 6 key strokes. This is not just a "cable" thing, TRUST ME! This is one of the main problems in America. EVERYONE (not just corporations) are looking at the "bottom line" as opposed to actually helping others (when was the last time anyone helped out their neighbor mowing the lawn, without expecting compensation?). Please keep tyhis in mind when deciding which company to go with. You can always go to the better business burea and get a report about any complaints a company received. "

Right on, MONA!!! wrote on Oct 19, 2007 10:16 AM:

" Feel free to go after Verizon next! "

If I had a hammer... wrote on Oct 19, 2007 8:44 AM:

" Anyone know the address for Mediacom? ;o) "

waco wrote on Oct 19, 2007 8:30 AM:

" comcast says they have 25 million satisfied customers well maybe 24 999 998 don't have the balls that these two have "

Casula Observer wrote on Oct 19, 2007 8:09 AM:

" Hurray for the lady! It's about time someone stood up to these megacorporations that abuse their customers. As for COMCAST becoming the local cable provider, I think I'll switch to Dish. The cable rates are going to go up, and obviously the customer service service will decline even more. "

to you go girl wrote on Oct 19, 2007 7:40 AM:

" no you can never get someone that speaks english. AOL ,earthlink,and others outsource there costomer service to india. i called insight c/s last week after i tried there free anti-virus program. it caused my computer to crash. and i couldnt get rid of it . when the man answered i couldnt understand him.. you would think that aol would at least use american workers..i mean come on look at the name. thats why i got rid of them and insight is next. this out sourcing of american jobs has got to stop. "

Tell me a better way.. wrote on Oct 19, 2007 4:58 AM:

" to handle this. I've been calling Allegiance Cable for the last 25 MONTHS and they've not FIXED my cable yet so we've turned them to the BBB and to the State's Attorney General. Still NOT FIXED. We are paying for services that WE ARE NOT RECEIVING. Now, we are video taping everything and are going to send it to the BBB and the State's Attorney General. Cable companies know when they have you by the gonads if there is only one provider where you live. I've been nice, I've been understanding, I've been mean talking and I've made threats to no avail, so my thoughts on this incident are: GOOD FOR YOU AND DO IT AGAIN IF YOU HAVE TO! MORE people need to take a firmer stance regarding cable service!! "

Mona help please wrote on Oct 19, 2007 12:38 AM:

" Strange to get this tonight. Just got run off the road in Chicago by of all things a Comcast service truck, who decided he needed to exit from the center lane with his rear wheels still by the door of my truck. Had to slamm on brakes and head to shoulder to keep from being hit by comcast jerk. Had lots of spilled product to pick back up in trailer. Thanks fool. Mona please help out and use your hammer on his pointy head to beat some sense into that idiot. "

trust me wrote on Oct 18, 2007 9:02 PM:

" i've debated waiting in the parking lot at a local business or two in this town. Just waiting for the creep who got "lippy" with me over their companies ridiculous stupidity. You know the deal , plumbers who never show up, cable guys, pizza delivery drivers. And when you call to complain they get an attitude even though they are in the wrong for failing to deliver what they promise. "

reader wrote on Oct 18, 2007 6:11 PM:

" Remember, isn't Com-cast going to be our cable company soon.Sad "

Michelle wrote on Oct 18, 2007 5:01 PM:

" LOL!! "

umm wrote on Oct 18, 2007 4:54 PM:

" Whoever wrote this article - you are a complete drama freak. It's annoying. "

Old News is Old wrote on Oct 18, 2007 4:53 PM:

" This was on Digg like two weeks ago "

Kill your TV wrote on Oct 18, 2007 4:02 PM:

" How about no cable or satellite? Is it really so impossible to concieve a life where you have to produce your own experiences and only be afraid of those things that might actually effect you? "

To: Good For Her wrote on Oct 18, 2007 3:53 PM:

" If you don't like it, don't watch it. "

You Go Girl!! wrote on Oct 18, 2007 3:20 PM:

" My compliments to Mona for having the guts to actually do something. Not that I condone violence, but boy would I have liked to have been a fly on the wall in that office. She must have a lot of patience to have waited outside in the heat for 2 hours, I know I would never have waited that long. Hopefully this will wake up a few companies and they can take a class somewhere on "Customer Service". Maybe while they are at it maybe they can get some people to answer the phone that actually understand the English language as well as speak it so others can understand what they said. "

I second Why, why ,why wrote on Oct 18, 2007 2:57 PM:

" Satellite only has a minor flaw and that is losing signal strength during a bad storm, but other than that it is so much better than cable. I'm willing to pay $100 per month on satellite because it is worth it. That's not counting the NFL and NBA packages, but they are the main reason I would never give up satellite. I gotta watch the Cowboys. "

Does Anyone Remember? wrote on Oct 18, 2007 2:38 PM:

" Does anyone remember when cable first came out? They promised no commercials because you'd be paying for their service? Aren't we a bunch of suckers? "

Why why why? wrote on Oct 18, 2007 2:33 PM:

" Why do people even bother with Cable anymore? Satellite is by far and away so much better it's silly. Cable? Please...I've not had cable in over 10 years. Best decision ever. "

lulz wrote on Oct 18, 2007 2:19 PM:

" She is a true hero of the masses. :) "

Good for her~~ wrote on Oct 18, 2007 2:06 PM:

" These companies take advantage of the little guy and then when you want to talk to someone they aren't available!!!! They charge us for the junk they call cable television. It's more like pornavision! I am so sick of people being murdered, their rear ends, and top ends it is disgusting. On some channels at around midnight you can hear them using the F*** word right out and it's not censored. I'm not a prude, but I worry about the kids that see and hear this every day and what the impact this has on them. Oxygen and PBS are about the only two channels that show decent shows. Television has sunk to an all time LOW!!! "

Alas success! wrote on Oct 18, 2007 1:59 PM:

" We have all been there, recently my husband attempted to get phone minutes back on a disposable phone. We had been sent a new SIM card that the company told us to install, when we did it erased all the minutes. How fun it was to be on hold with someone in a different country fighting the battles for those in high-rise America. One hour and ten minutes into the battle we were giving a complementary ten minute extra bonus and told to pick a different company if we didn't like it! Thank you, where do I send a check to help defer the cost of what you did for Americans! "

You go get 'em, sister! wrote on Oct 18, 2007 1:59 PM:

" Comcast sucks, but so does every other company anymore when it comes to customer service. The much talked about Nordstrom and their customer service...sucks. The world has truly gone to pot on this. "

good for her. wrote on Oct 18, 2007 1:36 PM:

" I can not tell you how many times I have wanted to do the same. God for her. Maybe this will wake them up and other companies and concentrate on customer service. "

Add your own comments

Please read the rules before posting comments.

You must be logged in to leave comments.
If you don't have a member ID, please register.

*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
  Forgot Your Password?