Pantagraph.com Weather forecast, local radar and more
NewsSaturday, November 24, 2007 12:38 AM CST
State to review special ed scores at Pontiac schools
Advertisement

PONTIAC -- Special education students in Pontiac elementary schools aren’t doing as well on standardized tests as the rest of the district’s students, and the state wants to know why.

Representatives from the Illinois State Board of Education will visit Pontiac’s elementary and junior high schools next week to conduct a three-day review of the district’s special education program. The review will run from Tuesday through Thursday, and it will include a public forum at 6 p.m. Tuesday in the Central Elementary School board room, 117 W. Livingston St.

“In general, this is what we could call a gap visit,” said Jodi Fleck, the state school board’s acting division administrator for special education. “We are looking to see if there are any specific reasons for the gap between regular students and IEP (individualized education plan) students.”

This is the first such visit for the Pontiac elementary school district, and Fleck said it is one of 29 school districts in Illinois designated for review.

The data used in determining the achievement gap came from the 2005-06 Illinois Standards Achievement Test, which is taken by third- through eighth-graders across the state.

On that test, 72 percent of the students met or exceeded the state average. Only 10 percent of Pontiac Junior High School special education students met or exceeded the state average.

All students in a grade level, including special education students, take the same test and are scored on the same standards.

Barbara House, special needs coordinator for the district, said there are 267 special education students in the district. Of those, 100 participate only in speech therapy.

The district includes three elementary schools and Pontiac Junior High School. The high school is in a separate district and not subject to the review.

State reviewers will look at student files, interview administrators and teachers and observe a typical classroom session. They also will allow the public and parents to comment and ask questions at the forum.

The main focus of the review will be on the subject of reading, a priority area selected by the state board, said Barbara House, special needs coordinator for the district.

“They will come back with recommendations of things that will need to be changed regarding the curriculum and to our school improvement plan,” House said. “They are going to tell us all of their concerns, and then we will have two years to make those changes.”

House said this will be the first time the district will be reviewed individually. The state board previously has conducted monitoring visits for the whole of Livingston County.




Public forum

What: Forum on the special education program in Pontiac’s elementary and junior high schools

When: 6 p.m. Tuesday

Where: Central Elementary School board room, 117 W. Livingston St.

Video
Most commented stories
Browse online archives
Recent issues:
Reader comments on this story - 8 total

Note: All views and opinions expressed in reader comments are solely those of the individual submitting the comment, and not those of the Pantagraph or its staff.

To: Public Forum wrote on Nov 24, 2007 8:37 PM:

" I think you may have missed something...sorry. I teach students with disabilities at the high school level, many of whom stay in school until the age of 21. Despite that, they either take the test or an alternate assessment, both which count toward the school's scores. They are not, however, exempt from participating. While I completely understand the efforts put into teaching students with a variety of disabilities, the state of Illinois requires ALL students, with or without disabilities from participating in those tests. Like I said, they can receive the accommodations they would typically receive in a testing situation, but as I said, all students, regardless of disability, participate. Unless the law changes by the time your child is in high school, this will happen to him as well. I am in no way saying it is fair, because it is not, but right now, this is what No Child Left Behind has helped produce. "

re: to Public Forum wrote on Nov 24, 2007 12:07 PM:

" I guess I could have missed something but I don't think so. My son IS exempt from the normal curriculum and will graduate high school when he is 21 years old.Some kids really do have developmental impairments and have had early intervention and the best treatment available since birth and despite their gargantuan efforts compared to their peers they still are not able to perform at grade level because they are bona fide developmentaly disabled. It happens. "

to: Public Forum wrote on Nov 24, 2007 10:22 AM:

" If your child is in elementary school, he/she may be able to be exempt from taking the state mandated tests. However, once they are in high school, there is no exemption. ALL students that are juniors are required by the state to take the PSAE (Prairie State Achievement Exam) and the ACT. They receive accommodations (but not paraphrasing, rewording, hints, clues, etc) and must take it. "

Sped Teacher and PTHS alum wrote on Nov 24, 2007 9:56 AM:

" I am currently a Cross-Categorical Sped teacher in a Champaign school. The one thing I've noticed about a lot of sped children is that a lot of these kids are highly capable. However, they need a little extra help and a push. Problem is, they get put in special ed at a young age and an IEP and they never get out. Not to mention they get told they're dumb and "special" all their lives so by the time they get to high school, they've given up. It's pretty sad. You should see what I have to deal with every day. Bright kids who are lazy, and they get to have speical accomodations. It's quite sad. It all goes back to the home. Someone should focus more on the correlation between crappy home lives and sped students. That should be the real study. "

Public Forum wrote on Nov 24, 2007 7:41 AM:

" Previous posters need to go to the forum.Students who do not perform at grade level are exempted from taking these tests just as my child was. But then they are sometimes just warehoused. Dist 429 DOES have a problem. I don't have to deal with it anymore because my child has moved into Dist. 90 now. Times are changing since there is a different superintendent and new members on the school board. This is definitely a good thing. One more person needs to retire and a qualified person needs to be hired to replace her.The current "coordinator" kept arguing with me when I told her my son's private psychologist diagnosed him as autistic. She wouldn't refer his records to Special Services so I went to a school board meeting and I call Special Services and the regional superintendent myself. She refused for FIVE YEARS to do a full evaluation of my son's cognitive assessment. Well...needless to say once I got special services attention they got involved and they did it...THEY DIAGNOSED HIM AUTISTIC AND SENT HER TO AUTISM TRAINING!I received an aplogy at that time from Mr. Jontry which was kind, I wish Dist 429 had fired her, though! "

Grandma wrote on Nov 23, 2007 9:09 PM:

" My grandson was in special ed in Pontiac and doing well....his family moved kankakee county school system...four years ago in Pontiac he tested at 3rd grade level...he is now at 1st grade level .........HMMMMMMM I think the state needs to look at Kankakee schools..............................Pontiac was GREAT! "

no, this is why wrote on Nov 23, 2007 7:37 PM:

" Did anyone think that perhaps their scores are lower because they are taking GRADE LEVEL state tests when they do NOT even perform at grade level?? Students should be taking exams at the grade level that they are performing at, then a true score of what the student knows is attained. These tests are ridiculous, and asking a SpEd student to perform as well as peers without disabilities is wrong! Those kids are frustrated, and these tests are designed for them to fail! In fact, I will go so far as to make a comparison that requiring SpEd students take grade level state exams is like making your 3 year old to do 8th grade Algebra! "

is that why wrote on Nov 23, 2007 6:02 PM:

" they have Individualized Education Plans (IEP) because they have specific learning or behavior needs. it shouldn't be a shock that their scores are lower. i think the state is just bored so they decided to take a little trip to Pontiac. "

Add your own comments

Please read the rules before posting comments.

You must be logged in to leave comments.
If you don't have a member ID, please register.

*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
  Forgot Your Password?