Pantagraph.com Weather forecast, local radar and more
NewsThursday, September 18, 2008 3:23 PM CDT
Employees, officials file lawsuit to stop Pontiac prison closure
Advertisement

PONTIAC -- The fight to keep Pontiac Correctional Center open headed to court Wednesday. Prison supporters filed a lawsuit arguing the state does not have a right to close the facility because it has budgeted money to run the prison through June 2009. | Will Blagojevich listen to vote? | Residents: Vote 'fantastic'

“We don’t want to be here, but we feel like our hand has been forced,” said Sen. Dan Rutherford, R-Chenoa.

The lawsuit, filed in Livingston County Circuit Court, claims Gov. Rod Blagojevich and the Illinois Department of Corrections cannot close the prison because funding was provided in the 2008-09 budget, which was passed by the Illinois General Assembly and signed into law by Blagojevich.

Chicago attorney Stephen Yokich, representing the American Federation of State County and Municipal Employees, said the appropriation is a legal duty that requires the state to fund the prison until the end of the fiscal year on June 30.

“Closing Pontiac is illegal and illogical,” AFSCME Council 31 Executive Director Henry Bayer said at a press conference at the Livingston County Courthouse.

In addition to AFSCME and Rutherford, others listed on the lawsuit filing include Republican state Reps. Keith Sommer of Morton and Shane Cultra of Onarga; Pontiac Mayor Scott McCoy and eight people who are either correctional workers or their families.

But a state spokesman said Wednesday the proposed closure should proceed.

“We haven’t seen the lawsuit yet, but we want to reiterate that the proposal (to close Pontiac Correctional Center) was very objective and in the best interest of the agency and state taxpayers,” IDOC Spokesman Derek Schnapp said.

In May, Blagojevich announced plans to close Pontiac Correctional Center by February and move roughly half of the 1,600 inmates to a largely unused prison in Thomson.

A local outcry ensued, and in the latest development, the bipartisan Commission on Government Forecasting and Accountability voted Tuesday in support of keeping the prison open. The recommendation from the panel of lawmakers is not binding.

AFSCME, the prison guards’ union, is the lead plaintiff in the lawsuit, and spokesman Anders Lindall said that it will pay for the cost of the legal action.

Yorkich said that a similar situation occurred in 2002 when a lawsuit was successful in getting a restraining order against the closing of Vienna Correctional Center.

State estimates put the savings from closing Pontiac at around $4 million per year, but opponents say it would have a devastating economic impact throughout Central Illinois.

The 560 correctional workers also would have to be transferred to other prisons or find new jobs, and the economic loss was estimated at $54 million.

Disrupting lives

Trina Keller, one of the plaintiffs who spoke at Wednesday’s event, fears the closure will disrupt her family’s life and harm her autistic daughter.

Keller and her husband, Jeff, moved from Rockford to Pontiac around 16 years ago when he became a correctional officer at the Pontiac prison. The have two children, Emily, 9, and Eric, 13.

Emily is autistic, and Keller worried about telling her daughter they will have to move because her father is being transferred to a new prison.

“We don’t want to sit there and explain to her that we are going to have to disrupt her whole life, everything that she has ever known, and it’s going to make her regress,” Keller said. “(Blagojevich) didn’t move his family to Springfield (when he was elected governor) and disrupt their lives.”

The Kellers are among four couples who are listed as plaintiffs in the lawsuit. They include prison workers who have family members with medical conditions that would make it devastating to move.

Keller is afraid that the situation has consumed her daughter, and that she might regress to the point where she doesn’t speak.

“Now I have to sit back and watch her race home from school to the TV or to the paper to see what has happened with the prison,” she said. “She shouldn’t have to worry about that.”

“She should be worrying about other things like what Hannah Montana is doing, not whether or not her dad is going to have a job.”

Video
Most commented stories
Browse online archives
Recent issues:
Reader comments on this story - 15 total

Note: All views and opinions expressed in reader comments are solely those of the individual submitting the comment, and not those of the Pantagraph or its staff.

real american wrote on Sep 18, 2008 3:32 PM:

" I am a PCC Guard. All the lawsuit does is buy time. Buy time for what is anyones guess. I am not a lover of our "union." I hate it when they allow management to violate the contract, so some of the more senior officers can keep their weekends off. However, Are they supposed to just give Blago. whatever he wants so they won't upset him? Dan Rutherford is not the only person to vote yes, when it came to the vote to put the recall provision question on this Novembers' ballot. They were voting to put a question on this Novembers' ballot, to ask the voters of this State, if we should have a provision added to our State Constitution, that would allow the recall of elected officials. Blagojevich is the one who made backroom deals with certain members of the Senate (Including the one who represents Joliet where Stateville is), to ensure we the people never get to vote on it. So, we have a Senator who was trying to give more power over our State Government to the voters, and a Governor who said we shouldn't have that much power over our government. "

niterider wrote on Sep 18, 2008 11:49 AM:

" As for the lawsuit, thats just shows you and all the people of pontiac that AFSCME
doesn't care if they make Blago mad. As for Dan Rutherford he is just using this for his own gain toward running for Govenor in 2010, Dan needs to save his money because he won't even come close, and he couldn't even beat Jesse White for Sec. Of State. "

wordsmith27 wrote on Sep 18, 2008 9:37 AM:

" To answer the questions posed by these posts!!!!: IDOC claims it will cost about $4.5 million less per year to run Thomson than Pontiac. However, closing Pontiac will take about $55 million annually out of the central Illinois economy. And, due to the proximity of the Thomson Correctional Center to the large metropolis of Clinton, Iowa and the lack of similar Illinois resources in the area, as much as $30 million of the expected economic boost to the Thomson area will be to the Iowa, not Illinois, economies. This move would trade a $55 million loss in one region for a $25 million gain in another.

When you add that financial equation to the facts that Pontiac is not falling apart and has had millions of dollars of renovations in the past decade both to replace aging plumbing, etc. and to add security upgrades to safely house the violent inmates who are housed there, the DOC's reason's for closing Pontiac and opening Thomson just don't hold up. "

keep-sarcasm-alive wrote on Sep 18, 2008 9:24 AM:

" I think I answered your questions, these posts!!!!!!. Even if we went by IDOC's figures, why would you close Pontiac that saves you 4 million, when you could close Stateville that saves you 31 million? This shows it isn't about savings.

And I don't think you are stupid for asking questions. I think we're all just a little raw right now from the criticism from people who don't know all the facts. "

these posts!!!!!! wrote on Sep 18, 2008 8:44 AM:

" ok I was simply asking questions I certainly didn't mean to insult anyone and I do have a sucure job in the medical field I did get an education and moved on. However no one really answered my questions. "

TheRudeAwakening wrote on Sep 18, 2008 8:32 AM:

" To These Posts . . . Go to the COGFA web site and watch the commission hearing. It will answer many of your questions. As for the age of the prison, the prison was recently renovated. We spent millions to accomplish this and speaking for myself, Pontiac prison is the SAFEST institution in Illinois. Tamms prison cannot even handle our inmates and ends up sending them back to us. I suppose because the White House is far older than our prison, we should tear it down for the safety of the presidency. This example may be extreme but it is your irrational thinking that produces it. As for your being laid off . . . find a MORE secure job. They're out there! "

keep-sarcasm-alive wrote on Sep 18, 2008 8:31 AM:

" these posts!!!!!!, please let me explain. Closing Stateville will save the state 31 million dollars (their figures, not mine). Closing Pontiac will save the state 4 million dollars (again their figures). And considering they have not included ALL the costs of moving inmates and running Thomson, I doubt there would even be a dime in savings to our state. "

PC02grad wrote on Sep 18, 2008 8:18 AM:

" To these posts!!!

You're not from Pontiac! That says it all right there! You have no idea how this is going to kill this county. I have lived here my whole life. My grandfather worked at that prison. I have been inside there and know many people who still work there. The building is fine! Again, you are not from Pontiac, so you really have NO IDEA!!! People like you is who gets me irritated. You post comments like that when you have no idea what the effect will be on the people who work there and the surrounding communities! It is the states governments problem. In a previous post...Blagojovich didn't want to uproot his family and move to Springfield for his job. DON'T MAKE PONTIAC PRISON WORKERS DO SOMETHING OUR OWN GOVERNOR WOULDN'T DO!!! "

Venture Bros. wrote on Sep 18, 2008 6:58 AM:

" This is what you get when you voted for Blago..and youll get more of the same if you elect his democrat friends in November. "

these posts!!!!!! wrote on Sep 18, 2008 5:51 AM:

" just a few questions If this is going to save the states millions of dollars why is that not ok? And I am not from pontiac but I have been there and the prison is old how safe is it? I understand people have many reasons why they wouldn't relocate but I can't see how that is the state or governments problem. What is the state offering? can you move and keep your jobs? I wish I had that option when I lost my job. "

Pontiac resident wrote on Sep 18, 2008 5:32 AM:

" When the Mafia does this, it's strong arm coercion. When Blagojovich does this, it's political pressure. What's the difference? Same crime, different outcomes. There has got to be a law to protect the people from this crime! "

observation8 wrote on Sep 17, 2008 11:01 PM:

" Governor Rod is a political hack x 5. "

ptownresident wrote on Sep 17, 2008 9:59 PM:

" This will only buy us time til June of '09. Then he can close us by vetoing out the $$ to operate Pontiac. Nice move! "

2tired wrote on Sep 17, 2008 8:38 PM:

" Okay if they win the suit, this will give congress time to change the law that it takes a Bipartisan committee to close a state agency not the governor alone. If congress doesn't do anything during this time it's nothing but a waste of tax payer’s money. "

the man wrote on Sep 17, 2008 4:36 PM:

" hmm what's that accomplish, another year of waiting and putting peoples lives on hold until Rod can close us in 09........ sounds like a plan. "

Add your own comments

Please read the rules before posting comments.

You must be logged in to leave comments.
If you don't have a member ID, please register.

*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
  Forgot Your Password?