Review: Casting goes against type in Barn II's 'Odd Couple' revisit

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

"Can two divorced men share an apartment without driving each other crazy?"

As the opening credits for the 1970s television version of Neil Simon's "The Odd Couple" roll, that question accompanies varying images of two entirely different men, one neat to a fault, the other unconcerned about anything hygienic, attempting to coexist in the Big Apple.

In the current production of this comedy classic, now playing at the Barn II Dinner Theatre, director Mary Simon goes against type, casting Bob Lane Jr. as "divorced, broke and sloppy" sportswriter Oscar Madison, and Pat Gaik as the fastidious neurotic Felix Unger.

The play opens as Oscar plays host at his weekly poker game. The slovenly Madison offers his guests warm beer, stale chips and a choice between brown sandwiches and green sandwiches. (The green sandwiches are either very new cheese or very old meat.)

Cohorts Ray, Speed, Vinnie and Murray the cop wonder aloud where the typically punctual Felix is, not realizing that at that moment, Felix's marriage was ending.

When he finally arrives at Oscar's, the melodramatic Felix is in shock, and contemplating ending his life. In a weak moment, Oscar suggests that Felix move in with him.

As their differences come hilariously between them, it doesn't take long for Oscar to regret his generous offer, especially after Felix ruins their big date with the charming Pigeon sisters.

Audiences at the Barn II have long enjoyed the pairing of Lane Jr. and Gaik, who fly through their well-choreographed banter with ease. This production will most certainly find a space at the top of the duo's playing list.

Equally in synch are Simon and Diann L. Thompson as the giggly Pigeon sisters, whose charms are only surpassed by their keen fashion sense.

Supporting players John Johnson, Dan Challacombe, Jon Steven Wiley and David Flanders round out the ensemble, whose efforts were rewarded with a standing ovation at this performance.


The Odd Couple

Venue: Conklin's Barn II Dinner Theater, Goodfield

Times and dates: Thu. through Sat. dinner shows, Sun. brunch matinees, through Nov. 2

Cost: $30 to $34

Running time: 2 hr., including 20-min. intermission

Print Email

/entertainment
 
Sponsored by:

4 Accused of Digging Up Bodies at Ill. Cemetary
4 Accused of Digging Up Bodies at Ill. Cemetary
Four cemetery workers have been charged with dismembering bodies after police found what they called 'startling and revolting' conditions at a historic cemetery near Chicago. (July 9)
Police: McNair Shot Dead in Sleep by Girlfriend
Police: McNair Shot Dead in Sleep by Girlfriend
Police in Nashville say former NFL quarterback Steve McNair was shot four times and killed by his girlfriend Sahel Kazemi, who then used the same gun to shoot herself in the head. (July 8)
What Happens to Jackson Mementos?
What Happens to Jackson Mementos?
With Michael Jackson's memorial service over, what will happen to all the gifts and flowers mourning fans have left behind at his family's house, his star on the Walk of Fame and Neverland Valley ranch. (July 8)
Obama: 'Not Too Soon' to Move on Health Care
Obama: 'Not Too Soon' to Move on Health Care
President Barack Obama says he recognizes the heavy price tag of revamping the health care system but that it would be much more costly to do nothing. (July 1)
First Person: Webster's New Words
First Person: Webster's New Words
Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary has added about 100 new words that largely reflect changing trends in American society. (July 9)