Guns N' Roses 'Chinese Democracy' a 17-year evolution

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

buy this photo An Aug. 31, 2006 file photo shows Guns N' Roses front man Axl Rose posing backstage at the 2006 MTV Video Music Awards in New York. (AP Photo/Stephen Chernin, File)

LOS ANGELES - When the last new Guns N' Roses album came out, there were no iPods or digital downloads. There was no "American Idol." No music blogs. No MySpace.

"Use Your Illusion" volumes 1 and 2 instantly topped the charts as simultaneous releases in 1991. Guns N' Roses was one of the hottest bands in rock 'n' roll - a sure hitmaker and stadium filler. Fans couldn't wait for the new material.

Now, 17 years later, that new material has arrived.

With an entirely new lineup - save for founding frontman Axl Rose - and after myriad stumbles and delays, Guns N' Roses' "Chinese Democracy" was released Sunday.

"Is this going to be 'Snakes on a Plane,' where the buildup is more exciting than the thing itself?" wondered Rob Brunner, senior editor for music at Entertainment Weekly.

Here's a look at the long evolution of the album that time almost forgot.

1994: Rose begins work on "Chinese Democracy."

1996: Guitarist Slash quits the band. Drummer Matt Sorum and bassist Duff McKagan follow. "That sort of seemed like the beginning of this album," Brunner said.

1998: Rose assembles a new band, including Nine Inch Nails touring guitarist Robin Finck and former Replacements bassist Tommy Stinson. They begin making music at Rumbo Recorders, where GNR's original lineup recorded parts of its multi-platinum 1987 debut, "Appetite for Destruction."

"That's when people started to think, 'What's he doing?' It seemed pretty bizarre to people who were fans of 'Paradise City,'" Brunner said.

1999: Rose invites Rolling Stone to preview tracks from "Chinese Democracy." The magazine anticipated the album could be released the following year.

2000: Rose hires two new musicians: guitarist Buckethead and drummer Brian "Brain" Mantia. The singer appears onstage for the first time in years during a surprise performance at a small Sunset Strip nightclub.

2001: Rose and the new GNR band perform new material at the House of Blues in Las Vegas.

2002: A cornrowed Rose and his band unveil a new track during a three-song medley at the MTV Video Music Awards. "What was striking about this is how little anyone was talking about the music," Brunner said. "It was all about his appearance and the fact that he showed up. It had nothing to do with the song itself. … That's when it started seeming like things were not going in the right direction."

2004: Geffen declares that it has spent enough money on "Chinese Democracy" and that it's Rose's "obligation to fund and complete the album." The label releases a Guns N' Roses greatest-hits record. The label did not respond to a phone call and e-mail seeking comment on the album's many delays.

2006: Rose announces that "Chinese Democracy" won't be released in 2006 as planned and sets March 6, 2007, as the new release date. Four tracks from the album leak online.

2007: "Chinese Democracy" does not materialize. More tracks leak online.

2008: In March, Dr Pepper announces it will give a free soda to everyone in America if "Chinese Democracy" is released before the end of the year. (The company says it is making good on its promise.) Two tracks are officially released in the fall: one in the "Rock Band 2" video game and another in the film "Body of Lies." In October, Geffen announces that "Chinese Democracy" will hit stores on Nov. 23. On Nov. 20, the album's 14 tracks stream on MySpace.com.

"This is his shot," Brunner said. "If this doesn't connect now, I don't think anyone, another 15 years from now, will be panting over the long-awaited follow-up to 'Chinese Democracy.'"


Music Review: GNR or not, a vote for 'Democracy'

By John Carucci

Associated Press

Guns N' Roses, "Chinese Democracy" (Geffen)

When an album takes longer to finish than the ceiling in the Sistine Chapel, lofty expectations are part of the deal. "Chinese Democracy" may not be high art, but for any GNR fan, it was certainly worth the wait.

The quality of the music was never much in question, seeing as Axl Rose had ample time to perfect it. The going concern has always been: With Rose as the only original member involved, is this to be considered a legitimate Guns N' Roses album?

Slash, Izzy Stradlin and Duff McKagen are all gone, chased off by their control-freak frontman at worst; or just long since moved on to the next thing. Keyboardist Dizzy Reed stuck it out with Rose over the years, but he didn't join the band until "Use Your Illusion" I and II in the early 1990s.

But where "Chinese Democracy" is technically more a Rose solo project than a Guns N' Roses album, it at least feels like the singer paying homage to his former band. Forgetting that for a moment, it is one heckuva record.

Rose's high-pitched, staccato delivery sounds strong as ever, and other GNR touchstones are revisited - from the six-minute piano ballad ("Sorry" is no "November Rain," but it has that feel) to a sampling of the same "failure to communicate" bit from "Cool Hand Luke" that he used as the introduction to "Civil War" in 1993.

The perfection of its warp-speed guitar solos, ambition of its proglike twists and turns, and flawlessness of its production are in line with the endless years "Chinese Democracy" took to make. Considering the carousel of characters who brought something to bear here, however, it's not surprising that its weakness is that the sum of these superior parts does not equate as a whole.

Maybe under normal time constraints, this would be considered a masterwork. Given the protracted production and soaring costs - an estimated $13 million - "Chinese Democracy," at best, meets expectations.

CHECK THIS TRACK OUT: "Madagascar" will easily fit into a playlist OF GNR's best. No surprise - Axl has played it live over the last couple of years.

Print Email

/entertainment
 
Sponsored by:

Video: Travell Arrington tribute
Video: Travell Arrington tribute
About 50 people gathered early Thursday evening to remember Travell Arrington, 10, who died after being struck by semitrailer truck on Tuesday at a west-side truck stop.
4 Accused of Digging Up Bodies at Ill. Cemetary
4 Accused of Digging Up Bodies at Ill. Cemetary
Four cemetery workers have been charged with dismembering bodies after police found what they called 'startling and revolting' conditions at a historic cemetery near Chicago. (July 9)
Police: McNair Shot Dead in Sleep by Girlfriend
Police: McNair Shot Dead in Sleep by Girlfriend
Police in Nashville say former NFL quarterback Steve McNair was shot four times and killed by his girlfriend Sahel Kazemi, who then used the same gun to shoot herself in the head. (July 8)
What Happens to Jackson Mementos?
What Happens to Jackson Mementos?
With Michael Jackson's memorial service over, what will happen to all the gifts and flowers mourning fans have left behind at his family's house, his star on the Walk of Fame and Neverland Valley ranch. (July 8)
Obama: 'Not Too Soon' to Move on Health Care
Obama: 'Not Too Soon' to Move on Health Care
President Barack Obama says he recognizes the heavy price tag of revamping the health care system but that it would be much more costly to do nothing. (July 1)