Juror says evidence against Harris too strong; appeal planned

2013-06-01T14:15:00Z 2013-07-19T19:16:56Z Juror says evidence against Harris too strong; appeal plannedBy Edith Brady-Lunny |

PEORIA — A Peoria County jury on Friday convicted Chris Harris of murdering five members of a Beason family, rejecting his claims of self-defense.

Harris looked down, his hands folded in front of him, at the defense table as Judge Scott Drazewski read the guilty verdicts on first-degree murder charges in the deaths of Ruth and Rick Gee and their children Justina Constant, 16, Dillen Constant, 14, and Austin Gee, 11, and the attempted murder of Tabitha Gee, who was 3 at the time, and survived the attack.

He also was convicted of home invasion, aggravated battery of a child and armed robbery.

The jury deliberated about 4½ hours over two days after a monthlong trial that was moved to Peoria after the defense successfully argued it would be difficult to secure a fair jury in Logan County.

The guilty verdicts did not come as a shock for the defense.

“We didn’t come into this with unreasonable expectations. We knew it would be tough,” said defense lawyer Daniel Fultz.

Seth Jones, 19, a member of the jury of seven women and five men, said after the verdicts that he looked for ways to believe Harris but the damaging evidence was too strong to ignore. Jones, a restaurant worker from Peoria, found it difficult some days to look at the gruesome crime scene photos.

A member of the Gee family hugged him after the verdicts, which were returned shortly after noon.

Harris, 34, of Armington faces life in prison when he sentenced July 19.

Logan County State’s Attorney Jonathan Wright, who handled the case with Illinois Assistant Attorneys General Mike Atterberry and Steve Nate, said the short deliberation “shows the jury believed the story presented in our case and that the evidence matched our charges.”

The verdicts reflect the jury’s rejection of Harris’ claim that he was forced to kill 14-year-old Dillen Constant. He claimed he entered the home and found the youth in the midst of beating the family members to death with a tire iron.

Harris testified that he and his brother, Jason Harris, 25, also of Armington, went to the Gee home to buy marijuana from Rick Gee, a known user of the drug. The visit followed a night of drinking, drug use and several attempts by Harris to connect with women.

Jason Harris’ testimony differed from his brother’s, beginning with what he said happened after Chris Harris pulled into the driveway. According to Jason Harris, Chris Harris slipped a tire iron up his sleeve as he headed for the house to talk to 16-year-old Justina Constant. A woman’s scream and loud thumps that sounded like a bowling ball were heard several minutes later from inside the house, Jason Harris told the jury.

Jason Harris, who originally faced the same charges as his brother, has reached a plea deal that includes a 20-year sentence for concealment of a homicide, drug sales and obstruction of justice for initially lying to police. When he receives credit for time served in jail and day-for-day credit for good behavior, he will be in prison for about six years.

For Fultz and fellow defense lawyer Peter Naylor, two factors were toughest to overcome with the jury, according to their comments after the case ended.

“The timeline and the multiple blows to the same area on the back of Dillen’s head” were the biggest defense challenges, said Fultz.

The state was able to substantiate the timeline that put the brothers in the home shortly after 12:30 a.m., when neighbors logged their last Internet conversation with Ruth and Rick Gee.

Members of the Harris and Gee families left the courthouse without making statements after the verdicts. Two rows of the courtroom were crowded Friday with relatives of the victims who commented earlier that they would be happy when a decision was returned.

For the family of Dillen Constant, the verdicts brought some sense of closure.

“We wanted our son’s name cleared and that was done,” said the boy’s stepmother, Terry Miller, who handed out photos of the child to reporters after the verdicts.

Copyright 2015 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(12) Comments

  1. andrewsmom
    Report Abuse
    andrewsmom - June 10, 2013 10:35 am
    There will be life with or without parole....that is where the difference lies
  2. OriginalMJ
    Report Abuse
    OriginalMJ - June 01, 2013 12:56 pm
    The death penalty ended when George Ryan was still in office, which was several years before this crime took place. So Harris will just have to rot in prison, and, sadly, we taxpayers have to pay to feed and house this scumbag.
  3. candymanfishing60
    Report Abuse
    candymanfishing60 - June 01, 2013 6:14 am
    The death penalty was still in force when they committed the crime i believe, so he should be sentenced ubder the old law and be given the death sentence..because he will adjust to prison life soon, and he well be protected in seg., so why should he live the rest of his life,. if he was put into population of the prison, then yes he would get what he had comming, just for hitting the little girl alone, alot of inmates have children, and they don't like it when someone hurts a child..Well at least the rot starts now, he well rot in there..But I don't believe the brother should get off easy, im sure he knew how his brother was, and he said he seen his brother take a tire iron with him in the house, then why didn't the brother try and stop it all,,i only hope the judge does not go along with the plea agreement for the other brother, as he does not have to and the judge well state that to Jason Harris before he sentence him..Jason should get the same-excuted, or life without parole., Jason Harris only stayed outside to be a watchout, in case someone or a cop would come by, he was just a lookout, so he could warn his brother, if someone was to come..anyone can tell that..those two were the devil, and his helper..bless that whole family where ever they are..t.s.
  4. earlyriser54
    Report Abuse
    earlyriser54 - May 31, 2013 7:18 pm
    The jury in this case got it right and kudos to them.
  5. tcubbies23
    Report Abuse
    tcubbies23 - May 31, 2013 6:52 pm
    RIP Gee family! Doubt you'll be seeing Harris after he departs this world!
  6. amandag2126
    Report Abuse
    amandag2126 - May 31, 2013 4:00 pm
    Death is the easy way out for him...he deserves to sit in prison for the rest of his pathetic life...I hope he rots in hell....may the gee family finally have some closure....
  7. OriginalMJ
    Report Abuse
    OriginalMJ - May 31, 2013 2:56 pm
    Glad to hear the verdict. The defense might have had a small chance at reasonable doubt if they hadn't waited THREE YEARS to come up with that self-defense story. If that had been what really happened, it would have been the first words out of Harris' mouth when he first encountered the police.
  8. lamo
    Report Abuse
    lamo - May 31, 2013 1:13 pm
    Life in prison - Illinois no longer has a death penalty.
  9. ladybee
    Report Abuse
    ladybee - May 31, 2013 12:54 pm
    There is no winner in this case. All those involved with the Gee family have lost loved ones. The family of the guilty individual has lost their son. For what reason, we might never know.
  10. peni1234
    Report Abuse
    peni1234 - May 31, 2013 12:49 pm
    give him the chair
  11. GirlsRoc
    Report Abuse
    GirlsRoc - May 31, 2013 12:48 pm
    Whoohooo.....Chris Harris will get what he deserves!!!!
  12. Nemo57
    Report Abuse
    Nemo57 - May 31, 2013 12:48 pm
    Justice has been served! May he have a long and miserable life in prison.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Happening today

Add an Event More

Featured Businesses

More Businesses