Editorial: Education reform will be long, hard path in Illinois

2012-11-18T08:00:00Z Editorial: Education reform will be long, hard path in IllinoisThe Pantagraph Editorial Board pantagraph.com
November 18, 2012 8:00 am  • 

The first step to solving any problem is getting accurate information on the extent of the problem.

In Illinois education, that step will be taken in elementary schools beginning next spring. And it’s not going to be pleasant.

As one of many reforms undertaken by the Illinois State Board of Education, elementary students next spring are going to be given a test that will more accurately judge whether they meet state standards. The Illinois State Achievement Tests (ISAT), which have been given in the past, show that 82 percent of students meet the state standards. What’s always been confusing is that the test given to high school juniors shows that 51 percent of the students meet the standards.

The students aren’t getting dumber as they age and the teaching at the high school level isn’t worse. It’s the tests that were wrong. Educators have known for some time that the ISAT test is simply too easy.

That’s going to change next spring and the results will shock some educators and many parents who have been misled into believing their students were doing well.

In a report released Tuesday by the respected education advocacy group, Advance Illinois, it was reported that about a third of Illinois students are proficient in reading by the fourth-grade level and about a third are proficient in math at the eighth-grade level. That means that a majority of our students are behind as early as the fourth grade. And once a student is behind, it’s hard to catch up.

The Advance Illinois report illustrates how hard: of 100 students who enter the ninth grade in Illinois, 71 will graduate from high school, 55 will attend a post-secondary institution and 29 will receive a post-graduate degree. That’s a dismal record, especially when you consider that eight out of 10 jobs in Illinois requires training beyond a high school degree.

The goal in Illinois is, by 2025, to have 60 percent of students receiving post secondary degrees. Advance Illinois advocates that the path to that goal involves more ambitious and rigorous instruction, collaborative and skilled teachers, effective school leaders, supportive environments including a renewed emphasis on counseling and involved families. Those are five goals that are easy to write down, but hard to achieve.

The good news is that Illinois has already laid the groundwork for a lot of this plan. The General Assembly and the State Board of Education are already involved in attaining more accurate data, increasing academic rigor and improving teacher and principal evaluation and training.

The concern is whether Illinois can stick to the plan. Changing educational outcomes will not happen overnight and everyone involved — and that includes parents and community members — must commit to making the changes that are necessary. It will also be challenging to take on these changes against the backdrop of a recovering economy and the state’s financial fiasco.

The alternative, however, isn’t acceptable. In the last decade — despite No Child Left Behind and many other school improvement programs — educational outcomes in Illinois have basically stayed the same. The state can’t afford to let another decade slip away.

Illinois has done a lot of working putting the reforms into place. But the harder work — turning ideas into realities and keeping with the plan — is ahead of us.

Copyright 2015 pantagraph.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(3) Comments

  1. Nshape
    Report Abuse
    Nshape - November 19, 2012 5:21 am
    What's irritating is the myth and hysteria that there is some huge problem that needs to be "reformed." When you start making demands that X amount of kids need to have post-secondary school, then you are setting yourself up for failure because that "goal" is out of your control. Post-secondary degrees are an individual choice. Now should schools at least set kids up for success with the knowledge to get there? Absolutely. But some kids are going to learn the hard way, and some of these bonehead "reformers" have got to realize that not everyone is cut out for college. This is like a dentist saying "By 2020, 60% of my clients will not have cavities." Sure, it sounds good but good luck when people make choices out of your control.
  2. Harcourt
    Report Abuse
    Harcourt - November 19, 2012 2:59 am
    I've watched educational reform since the 1980's and I've never seen it accomplish anything. Keep the state and feds out of local education, and let local boards set their standards. The state and feds have done nothing except waste resources for the past 30 years. If they haven't figured it out by now, they never will.
  3. ashlein80
    Report Abuse
    ashlein80 - November 18, 2012 8:21 pm
    How about more days spent in school? I am astounded by the amount of late start, teacher work days and holidays students get. Last year there were 8 late start days. This year? Let's bump it up to 14! They give them days out in junior high (middle) school for the Normal and Normal West homecoming. Does this make any sense? It seems as if they are out, going in late, or finding whatever excuses for students not to be in school and the be surprised by the testing outcome.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Pantagraph Blogs