Triana James of Normal, left, makes a family portrait of Clare Baez, of Bloomington, and her sons, Fergus, 18 months, and Finnegan, 4, against the mural at 104 E. Beaufort St. Monday, May 13, 2019. Local artists are hoping to stop the town from moving the mural to another location.

NORMAL — A judge will decide May 20 whether or not to issue a temporary restraining order to stop construction crews from relocating a mural in uptown Normal, which at one point was slated for demolition.

On Monday in U.S. District Court in Peoria, Judge Joe Billy McDade heard arguments from the plaintiffs of a lawsuit filed April 24 by local artists who hope to protect the mural they painted on the wall of a building at Uptown Circle.

The judge indicated he hopes the two sides can find a compromise before the next scheduled court date.

Originally, the town indicated the mural would be torn down, but in the lawsuit, several of the artists asked for a temporary restraining order to block it from being moved. On Friday, attorneys for the town filed papers revealing plans to move the mural — intact — to another, unspecified location. They confirmed their intentions in court Monday not to destroy the mural, but only to relocate it — at a cost of almost $100,000.

The mural is the product of about 30 local artists, who created it in 2011 at the request of The Pod, an art and gift store that once occupied the building at 104 E. Beaufort St. It and two other buildings will be torn down for construction of the five-story Trail East building, a $30 million project.


Keith Carver of Las Cruces, N.M., and his grandson, Caleb Maestas, 3, walk past the mural at 104 E. Beaufort Monday, May 13, 2019, as they visited the Children's Discovery Museum.

“To preserve the mural, the Town has arranged to remove the mural from the building and relocate it,” state court documents. The plaintiffs were notified of those intentions in March, according to the papers filed in court.

The plaintiffs are represented by Chicago attorney William McGrath, who was unavailable for comment Monday.

The court filings do not indicate where the mural might be relocated, but according to a report completed by the Farnsworth Group, included in the documents, the removal and relocation would cost $99,450.

OttoBaum Contractors, based in Morton, was selected to remove the mural wall and frame, estimated to weigh about 70,000 pounds and standing 13 feet tall.

The plans to move the mural involves reinforcing the mural in a steel frame and lifting it out onto dollies for transportation.

“The work will be performed by experts in the field of historic preservation,” according to the Town’s response to the court. “These experts have examined the building and the mural and have concluded that the mural can be relocated.”

On Monday, McDade ordered the parties to file supplemental briefs regarding the display and or relocation issues prior to the May 20 hearing, set for 10:30 a.m. in Peoria.

Artists sue Normal, developer ahead of uptown mural's destruction

The Town is represented by Brian Day who was not available for comment Monday.

City Manager Pam Reece also could not be reached for comment Monday, but said previously the town “will appropriately defend its position to move forward with the plan for development.”


A message on the mural at 104 E. Beaufort St. takes on a hopeful outlook that the controversy between local artists who painted the mural and the town can be solved.

Reece also previously said a date for any demolition or movement of the mural had not yet been set.

If the judge grants the restraining order, the town and co-defendant in the case, Bush Development, would be “prohibited from the destruction, distortion, mutilation or other modification of the mural.”

In papers filed by McGrath, he argues the artwork is protected by the federal Visual Artists Rights Act that also gives the plaintiffs the right to decide how and where the mural can be displayed.

Photos: Looking back on uptown Normal's mural

Coming soon: Get Government & Politics updates in your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Contact Kevin Barlow at (309) 820-3238. Follow him on Twitter: @pg_barlow


Agriculture Reporter

Agriculture reporter for Lee Enterprises Central Illinois.

Load comments